I gotta say I have the tucker and I don't love it. Its well made but I do think its a little pricey for what it is. My major problem though is I just don't find that it hides as well as some of my other more traditional holsters. I think this will vary greatly though depending on body type and where you wear your gun. Remember when you order that generally a p99c will fit in anything that a 2004+ p99 will fit in. You'll have a little extra leather at the end but you might have more options if you ever get the fullsize plus you'll find it easier to find the holster you want.