I agree with jmoln. The Delfatti holster is superb, but you may have to wait a while on delivery. I love mine. Comp-Tac makes a Kydex paddle holster that works beautifully too. Comp-Tac's customer service and turn-around time is outstanding. Comp-Tac often ships the next day. Whichever one you choose, you should be able to use a .40SW and the 9mm. As I recall, I told Matt Delfatti that I had both and he simply used the .40SW to mold the holster. I believe Gregg at Comp-Tac did the same thing, too. Both work beautifully.