I have a Fobus, Comptac Kydex, and a Fist Leather.
They all have their pro's and con's,
Fist Leather - Belt Attached
Pros: Nice Fit, quiet, positive retention, nice storage holster
Cons: Need a extra long and thick belt, might wear out, probably not quite as secure as others (running or jogging)
Fobus Paddle
Pros: Cheap, Positive retention, lightweight
Cons: Material seems flimsy (Plastic), paddle can rock forward and back mesing up cant
Comptac Kydex Paddle
Pros: Adjustable retention, has tabs to prevent rocking, lightweight, small in size.
Cons: No positive retention (held by friction, no click lock in), bit harder to get on
They all have their pro's and con's,
Fist Leather - Belt Attached
Pros: Nice Fit, quiet, positive retention, nice storage holster
Cons: Need a extra long and thick belt, might wear out, probably not quite as secure as others (running or jogging)
Fobus Paddle
Pros: Cheap, Positive retention, lightweight
Cons: Material seems flimsy (Plastic), paddle can rock forward and back mesing up cant
Comptac Kydex Paddle
Pros: Adjustable retention, has tabs to prevent rocking, lightweight, small in size.
Cons: No positive retention (held by friction, no click lock in), bit harder to get on